mn-msta.com

General Category => General Banter => Topic started by: gely on December 31, 2011, 11:47:54 AM

Title: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: gely on December 31, 2011, 11:47:54 AM
Good article by Dylan Code, not sure if he's related to Keith Code.
Starts on page 4.
www.public.navy.mil/navsafecen/Documents/media/seashore/smartride/SmartRide2011.pdf (http://www.public.navy.mil/navsafecen/Documents/media/seashore/smartride/SmartRide2011.pdf)
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: Tim... on December 31, 2011, 05:33:50 PM
Dylan is Keith's son.  He was the lead instructor when I did CSS at VIR last year.   Great communication skills, sense of humour and a hell of a nice guy.

Nice read, thanks for posting.
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: Joel S on January 01, 2012, 06:22:23 AM
so does a safer bike equate to riding on the electronics, trac control and abs, or is that there just as an extra safety step??
i have abs and can could on one hand how many times it has kicked in, others seem to hammer the brakes soooo hard it is always oninterestinging advancements though
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: gely on January 01, 2012, 09:52:21 AM
so does a safer bike equate to riding on the electronics, trac control and abs, or is that there just as an extra safety step??
i have abs and can could on one hand how many times it has kicked in, others seem to hammer the brakes soooo hard it is always oninterestinging advancements though

From the article, seems like they left all the electronics on and results in less crash vs. prior year.  I know its not scientific, but its the best data I've seen.
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: vince on January 01, 2012, 10:29:48 AM
Well I would go back to the mnsbr forum to your thread that you started when you bought the bike and posted pictures of it. I would post this and clear your name a hole. Lol.
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: Tim... on January 01, 2012, 11:14:34 AM
Ok, I am going to start a collection of Vince'isms... "I would post this and clear your name a hole"
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: vince on January 01, 2012, 11:33:46 AM
For some of you they call him that on that forum because he had that bike.
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: Tim... on January 01, 2012, 12:28:00 PM
#2
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: gely on January 01, 2012, 08:50:41 PM
Well I would go back to the mnsbr forum to your thread that you started when you bought the bike and posted pictures of it. I would post this and clear your name a hole. Lol.


Haha Vince, that maybe the funniest things I've heard you say.  I have no problem with that thread, I think its funny as hell.
For those that don't know what Vince is talking about here's the old thread.  If you got 30 minutes to kill, read it.
I can't promise you'll get your 30mins back if you think it was a wasted time.

http://www.mnsportbikeriders.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=52583&st=0&p=812931&hl=s1000rr&fromsearch=1&#entry812931 (http://www.mnsportbikeriders.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=52583&st=0&p=812931&hl=s1000rr&fromsearch=1&#entry812931)
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: Hope2Ride on January 01, 2012, 08:54:42 PM
Well I would go back to the mnsbr forum to your thread that you started when you bought the bike and posted pictures of it. I would post this and clear your name a hole. Lol.

LMAO! Vince there is no such thing as clearing your name over there. You're either in their elite group of assholes or an outsider douchebag. But go ahead Ge and post it up! I agree with Vince!
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: tk on January 03, 2012, 03:00:27 PM
For some of you they call him that on that forum because he had that bike.

They are probably just jealous because Ge has a nicer bike than most of them have.
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: carlson_mn on January 03, 2012, 09:20:14 PM
Well I would go back to the mnsbr forum to your thread that you started when you bought the bike and posted pictures of it. I would post this and clear your name a hole. Lol.

LMAO! Vince there is no such thing as clearing your name over there. You're either in their elite group of assholes or an outsider douchebag. But go ahead Ge and post it up! I agree with Vince!

Wow, while I'm a total outsider to that whole thread/community I did read most of that and wow that was painful, so many idiots. 

The best was the guy who said that if you have ABS it will be bound to fail and that you WILL end up doing an endo because of you'll have no idea how to brake. (As if it does all braking for you???)

Like Joel said in 50k miles on ABS bikes I've had it come on about 2 times for a few milliseconds when braking heavily, other than practicing in a parking lot where I can tell you that ABS allows you to have confidence in braking and keeping your wits about you and not worrying about the front tire locking up and dumping you on the ground - which is how I had my only street crash back in '99.
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: Tim... on January 04, 2012, 06:25:02 PM
I say rejuvenate your original thread and post the article back over to MNSBR... explode some heads.  Entertaining to say the least. 
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: Hope2Ride on January 05, 2012, 03:46:41 AM
I say rejuvenate your original thread and post the article back over to MNSBR... explode some heads.  Entertaining to say the least. 

+1 it takes almost nothing to make heads explode! Someone started a thread about the Ghost Riders and of course they are extremely misinformed about us. I made one comment that I was a Ghost Rider and played nice and they still got their panties in a bunch so I dropped it..... Ge, let's go revive some entertaining threads! LOL its winter and everyone is getting bored
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: aschendel on January 05, 2012, 11:47:00 AM
good thread over there, crazy for sure.

i still wonder how ABS will work once a bike leaves the pavement, i.e. running wide on a corner into the grass, but the ABS won't let the tires slip and you can't stop prior to the trees 100 yards away.  that's my fear/scenario...  or if you follow someone when the road randomly turns to gravel (I've heard this can happen :/ ) and they control-skid to a stop digging a trench while ABS does its thing and you hit them going 10 or 20 mph or something...  not dissing the tech, just wondering how it'll help when the lack of adhesion lasts longer than you want it to.

a.s.
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: carlson_mn on January 05, 2012, 12:33:14 PM
good thread over there, crazy for sure.

i still wonder how ABS will work once a bike leaves the pavement, i.e. running wide on a corner into the grass, but the ABS won't let the tires slip and you can't stop prior to the trees 100 yards away.  that's my fear/scenario...  or if you follow someone when the road randomly turns to gravel (I've heard this can happen :/ ) and they control-skid to a stop digging a trench while ABS does its thing and you hit them going 10 or 20 mph or something...  not dissing the tech, just wondering how it'll help when the lack of adhesion lasts longer than you want it to.

a.s.

In my experience it works fine on gravel, think about braking on gravel... tires don't lock up right away, you can brake pretty good before that happens, and ABS lets you do that and keeps you right on the brink.  Now if you're out having fun on gravel on a GS or whatever, well it'd be nice to turn it off which you can on most of those bikes so you can slide it around as you like. 

If a bike is going wide and running into ditches.... well ABS won't help you there, but I'd still rather have it on grass than not have it.  Front brakes and tire will wash out in no time on grass if it locks up in my experience.  But I think either way that's a bad situation where you better be able to ride it out.
Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: gely on January 05, 2012, 03:24:29 PM
good thread over there, crazy for sure.

i still wonder how ABS will work once a bike leaves the pavement, i.e. running wide on a corner into the grass, but the ABS won't let the tires slip and you can't stop prior to the trees 100 yards away.  that's my fear/scenario...  or if you follow someone when the road randomly turns to gravel (I've heard this can happen :/ ) and they control-skid to a stop digging a trench while ABS does its thing and you hit them going 10 or 20 mph or something...  not dissing the tech, just wondering how it'll help when the lack of adhesion lasts longer than you want it to.

a.s.


Andy-  I have experienced your fear and lucky for me, I wasn't hurt, and was able to ride to Push Mtn road and back home.  We were doing ~70-80mph through that corner in the picture below while riding in Arkansas. I thought there's no-way I'm going to make it even if I leaned some more, so I decided to stand the bike up and tried to ride through the yard.  As soon as the bike was up, I grabbed hand full of brake, knowing worse case my front tire would wash out, but I would land on the grass. 

My front tire didn't wash out and I was able scrub off a lot speed until I noticed there was a fence and trees up ahead, I then decided to jump off the bike. 

I believed that if I didn't have ABS I would have crashed as soon as I hit the grass, very close to where tk crashed.



This picture shows mine and tk's path.
(http://i44.tinypic.com/2vtu0ls.jpg)


My path and trees and fence up ahead.
(http://i41.tinypic.com/16bgd3s.jpg)

Title: Re: Cali Superbike School BMW S1000Rr Is Safer
Post by: aschendel on January 05, 2012, 03:39:31 PM
Ge, you'd be singing a completely different song had you ridden off a cliff at 10mph 100 yards from the road, but I definitely hear what you're saying and appreciate the first-hand insight.

I know I'm being paranoid about a specific short-coming (it takes longer to stop *in some situations*), but I've rolled through enough intersections in my car with ABS clicking away full blast in the snow (yea! I can steer but I can't stop!) to feel like it's an important question for me.  I would just hate to crash into a ride leader who can non-ABS skid to a stop before my ABS-equipped bike can stop...  In my car I can use the hand-brake but there isn't such an option on the bike.  It might not end up working right, but I think it would be sweet to have the rear ABS elongate the pulses if activated for a large enough distance.

a.s.